AUTHORS
William Joseph Archibald, MD, CPA, Frank Akwaa, MD2, Craig Maguire3, Bassil Botros, MD4, Kevin Zablonski, MD5
AFFILIATIONS
1 University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, New York, United States
2 University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, New York, United States
3 University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, New York, United States
4 University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, New York, United States
5 University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, New York, United States
ABSTRACT
Background
In January 2019, US Medicare began to reimburse providers for electronic consultation (eConsult) services. Under the US Medicare model, eConsults are reimbursed at 0.7 wRVU (work relative value unit – a measure of cognitive effort by the physician for providing these services) whereas face-to-face (F2F) consults with a classical hematologist for a low complexity visit (the encounter type eConsults aim to replace) are reimbursed at 1.6 wRVU. Commercial payers in the US typically follow this Medicare payment model and physician reimbursement and productivity targets are most commonly based on wRVUs.
Despite this reimbursement disparity, eConsults have seen success in improving provider satisfaction under capitated models with shifting of responsibilities to other team members (Pai Blood 2019, Cecchine Blood 2016). eConsults have also been shown to improve access and timeliness of care for certain conditions in fee-for service models, making them a valuable service for classical hematologists to offer within a health system (King EJH 2024). At our institution, 4 classical hematologists perform eConsults, with each physician performing 3 months of eConsult coverage per fiscal year.
However, an analysis of lost physician compensation for cognitive effort performed but not recognized under this fee-for-service model has not been performed.
Methods
Six months of eConsult referral data was analyzed retrospectively from August 2024 through May 2026, evaluating every 4th month. eConsults were characterized as “billed” if completed or “converted to F2F” if a F2F consultation was deemed warranted or “declined” if the question was not appropriate for eConsult. Volume growth and projected volume growth were modeled using ordinary least squares. To assess for lost cognitive effort wRVUs at the physician level, lost cognitive effort wRVUs were estimated at 0.9 wRVUs per billed eConsult. This assumes if a F2F consultation was performed instead of eConsult, it would be considered a low complexity office visit under a fee-for-service model. For eConsults declined or converted to F2F, 0.7 wRVUs (representing the effort of reviewing the case where billing for eConsults is not allowed). wRVUs for lost physician compensation were valued at $90/wRVU per Marit Health 2025 average hematology/oncology compensation.
Results
During the 6 months examined in detail, 384 eConsults were requested. 226 (58.8%) of eConsults were billed. 130 (33.9%) of eConsults were converted to F2F consults. 28 (7.3%) of eConsults were declined, largely due to consults for thrombosis and hemostasis which are required F2F consults at our institution. An average of 3 eConsults per business day were received.
Median time to respond to an eConsult was 12 minutes, consistent with previously published data of approximately 15 minutes per eConsult (Pai Blood 2019; Cecchini Blood 2016). This was consistent regardless of whether the eConsult was billed, converted to F2F, or declined as physicians reported examining the case to determine appropriateness for eConsult and providing recommendations for initial laboratory or imaging investigations to allow for more productive F2F consults.
For lost cognitive wRVU per fiscal year at the individual physician level, a total of 157 wRVUs/fiscal year were not captured due to the use of eConsult. 101.7 wRVUs were lost due to utilizing eConsult instead of a low complexity F2F consult and 55.3 wRVUs were lost due to conversion to F2F visits or declined eConsults. This represents $14,130 of lost cognitive compensation at the individual physician level per fiscal year.
Volume of eConsults has grown roughly 20 eConsults per year across the sampled period (+1.67 eConsults/month - SE 0.64) or approximately 2%/year, mirroring the growth of our health system’s primary care referral base for which this consultation model is intended for.
Conclusion
This analysis demonstrates that eConsults create a significant uncompensated cognitive workload burden on the classical hematology workforce of approximately $14,000/year. To attract more individuals to the field of classical hematology in line with the American Society of Hematology goals (Wallace Blood 2015), health systems and public policy makers must ensure that use of eConsult does not result in lost cognitive effort wRVUs and resulting compensation at the individual physician level.
DISCLOSURES
William Joseph Archibald, MD, CPA: Sanofi - Speakers Bureau.; Sanofi - Membership on a Board/Advisory Committee